BB | Ruby to garnet pink. Open, complex, smoky, black-and-red-fruit, mineral nose, with hints of road tar, crushed stones, wild fennel, and oriental spices. Medium-bodied, lively, uplifted palate, with great acidity, fine tannins, and a sweet-cherry finish. 94
AJ | Deep but clear and translucent black-red. Fine spice and herbal notes, but at first it seems to lack a little freshness and precision compared to the best of its peers. A very attractive aromatic profile nonetheless: pure Etna, serene and harmonious now with some bottle age. I come back 20 minutes later and the freshness is gathering and lifting, so this is an authoritative wine that needs time and air, despite its six years of age. Orchestral, complete, and harmonious. Very good on the palate, with a sense of vitality and drama (thanks to magnificently articulate tannins) that wasn't evident on the aromas. A totally commanding wine, deep and tight-hewn still; a huge amount still to give. 2017 was obviously a special vintage here and this still has a long way to go. 94
MP | A surprisingly fresh and vibrant nose, with cooked cherry, pomegranate, plum, and some earthy notes. At least it isn't oxidized. The finish leads with red currant, cranberry, and plum, supported by attractive levels of acidity, tannins, and tertiary complexity. This is drinking well now, although there is no rush. 92