Michael Edwards: Very pale color. Reserved on the nose, citrussy, not saying much. Pale, fresh, but maybe a bit dormant. Healthy, but no fireworks. | 89

Simon Field: Soft modest color. Stone fruit, hints of peach and plum; a smoky character, a touch of reduction; gentle dosage, and a poised discrete finish; an elegant apéritif syle. | 88

Anne Krebiechl: A subtle florality plays on the citrus nose. The palate is still taut, almost raw, with freshness. The mousse is lively and brisk. This seems too young, too disturbed after being woken from its slumber on lees. Right now, all is freshness, urgency, and energy. The balance is there, so is the hinted-at depth. Perhaps it is the tasting sequence, but this seems so very young and raw. The finish is Lip-smacking, moreish, and long. | 93