Andrew Jefford | Clear red. Slightly odd scents; almost a fish-skin note, and something a little ashy. Sharp, hard, and with those same ashy notes; a touch of herbaceousness, also. A little awry, and not really drinkable for me. | 76

Anne Krebiechl | Freshness on the nose combines ripe, red cherry and hints of smoke. The palate has a slender, but distinct concentration and vivid tartness. There is a stony core of firm, alluring depth, while red fruit plays gently around the edges. Alcoholic heat is palpable but serves to heighten rather than to subdue. This is powerful and fresh. | 94

Jancis Robinson | Mid-garnet. Bright color. Some sweat and cumin on the nose. Good fresh fruit with an edge but it’s not mellow. Drying tannins on the end. Needs a little more fruit. Light and a bit tart. | 88