Simon Field | Accessible and pleasant on the nose, with peaches and cream, ginger stem, and vanillin; pleasurable, principled, international in scope, concentrated but not too rich—a thoroughly modern style that flatters but does not, necessarily, deceive. | 88

Andrew Jefford | Mid-gold. Plenty of aromatic richness here, but delivered with a slightly forceful, foursquare style. On the palate, the wine is deep, marrowy, long, structured, powerful, and compelling— better than the aromas suggested. This is a serious contender and built for the long haul; perhaps one might hope for a little more charm in youth, but no one will be disappointed by this concentrated, powerful, and masterful white Châteauneuf-du-Pape. | 92

John Livingstone-Learmonth | Firm yellow robe. Toffee, musky white raisin, elderberry, and peanuts mix on the nose. The palate is centered on a trim ball of richness, with the brakes still on, as if the wine has just been bottled—hence the toning down on the finish. Allow it at least another year; it’s only half a wine for now. There is a little lime on the aftertaste, a note of minted freshness there. 2018–25/27. | 87