Stephen Brook: Closed nose. Sweet-and-sour tone, pear drops; too tart for my palate, with eye-watering acidity. Not ripe enough. a

Jancis Robinson: Low-key, rather shy impact on the nose. Full, exciting, lovely balance on the palate. This one is coming up on the inside straight - very arresting. Quite long and impressive. Lots of ripe-fruit character. 15.5

Alexander Scott: Ripe but restrained. This made, but I can 't find individuality. Perhaps it just is well much suffers from following the Breuer Rauenthal Nonnenberg. Tentative score, which may be on the mean side. 14