Michel Bettane: Neat, well balanced but not very complex. 13.5

Simon Larkin : Pale in appearance. Discreet, fresh aromas of mineral fruit. The palate reveals some poise, though the fruit shows a hazy complexity. There is, however, a good bready, yeasty complexity that adds interest. The mousse seems less significant in aiding a vinous aspect to this particular cuvee. Modest to good length on the finish. 14.5

Anthony Rose: Youthful pale gold. Fine nose, oozing class and richness. Intense, lovely, creamy mouth-filling mousse on the palate, elegantly styled with undertones of grilled nuts and toffee, and an exotic, pineapple-citrus freshness. Nice fruit flavours; crisp and stylish. 17