Michel Bettane: Pale colour; uncomplicated taste and technically faultless, but a bit vulgar to my mind. 12

Simon Larkin : The appearance is mid-lemon. The aromas seem muffled, with little coming to the surface. Green-fruit elements to the fore. Angular, aggressive and impure. There is little that is positive in this example at this stage. Very citrussy, clearly young, but will harmony come with age? I doubt it. 12.5

Anthony Rose: Youthful pale gold. Shy nose, lacks a bit of expression. Better on the palate, with some richness, creamy fruit character and appealing citrussy acidity. An elegant, youthful style with plenty of time to go. 15