Michel Bettane: Unmistakably oxidised nose - very short palate. 11

Simon Larkin : Egg-yolk yellow. Disappointing aromas here - faulty. Shocking palate, all over the place. Edgy, disjointed and angular. Very poor indeed. Minimal expression of fruit. What on earth is this? 6.5

Anthony Rose: Deep yellow-gold. Aged to the point of cideriness on the nose. Unusual palate, very individual, quite dry and austere, and a creamy mousse. Rather charmless and ungenerous finish. 14