Stephen Brook: Muted nose. Broad, a touch flabby, especially for Puligny, though it has some bite on the mid-palate, fails to thrill; medium length. 15

Andrew Jefford: Pale yellow-gold. Aromatic profile is slightly damped down and cardboardy; little fruited charm. Sample? Vivid, lively, bright but slightly clunky. No problem with concentration, but the fashioning of the raw materials seems coarse. 13