Michael Edwards: Yet again, a minty/eucalyptus scent, almost New World; lovely poised fruit on the palate: very elegant and fine. Some stem character here, but I like its positive nature-17

Andrew Jefford: Dark black-red. Another wine with those rather kerosene-like, herbal aromas of imperfect ripeness. Soft, supple, full, this graceful wine retains some fresh fruit and has freshness and poise. The finishing tannins are licoricey and sustained, and the soft acidity is supportive. There is, though, little precision or nobility to it-13

Marcel Orford-Williams: A late arrival but worth the wait. Full fruit, some richness. Mean finish, almost austere, yet with some sweetness. Drink now-14.5