Alex Hunt: 79

Andrew Jefford: Dark purple-red. Very clean, with fruits and flowers and spices all tucked away, somewhere or other: a St-Amour of great aromatic charm, once you give it a little air. Lovely depths and textures in here, busying around the fruit and giving it a charge and grandeur that few of its St-Amour peers have matched. Absolute classicism and depth. 91

Peter Liem: This is tannic and constricted, feeling a little one-dimensional in its fruit flavors. It’s juicy and fragrant on the palate, without really developing in character. 84