Michel Bettane: Fruity nose but not completely ripe; light body, no aggressive tannins, no length—drinkable 13

Thierry Desseauve: Red, but a paler color than the other Jean Guyon wines. Young and quite pure fruit, long and fresh; good balance and elegant style 15

Michael Schuster: Closed to smell as yet; nicely balanced light, fresh, supple claret, with a light tannin, a juicy ripe red fruit, and nice light length. Now–2018 14