Michel Bettane: Good dark color, precise nose; good oak integration, medium body, not very ripe berries but nice extraction. Well made but average vintage there. 14.5

Thierry Desseauve: Slim and elegant, with a good acidity and fine tannins. The fruity aromas are blended with fine cedar notes; quite long. Not a big wine but a good one. 15.5

Michael Schuster: Closed but minerally nose; ripe, supple, middleweight wine, lightly, dryly tannic; easy, pleasing fresh blackcurrant and mineral Cabernet flavor; moderate complexity and length. Now–2018. 14.5