Tim Atkin: Pale lemon/straw, with a hint of green. Floral, slightly reductive notes, with a hint of orange peel. A touch of residual sugar on the palate, balanced by sappy acidity. Pear and apple fruit, well-balanced acidity, and nice texture and concentration. Light and refreshing but with good depth 16

Nicolas Belfrage: 1 = color of water and 9 = deep gold: Col 2. Slightly less fresh, slightly more perfumed. Good weight on the palate but a little less zing compared with previous 14

Alex Hunt: A very ripe style, with aromas heading away from herb or mineral notes into dried apricot. The lowish acid emphasizes a slightly phenolic aspect, and there are some animal flavors on the palate that, strangely, recall Fiano. A lot of appeal up-front but not the grace and subtlety of the other Kerner here 15