Nicolas Belfrage: (cc: water-pale = 1; deep gold = 9) cc3. Fresh and clean without great character. Good German acid but plenty of flavor, too; unfortunately, however, it is a bit predictable. Quite good length- 13

Marcel Orford-Williams: Apples. Quite full, fat, and yellow. Rich; sweet ’n’ sour fruit; mushroomy finish. Not great. Short- 10.5

Joanna Simon: Medium pale, with a touch of green. Fresh, sappy, nutty nose. Ripe, honeyed, oak-enriched fruit on the palate. A full, ripe, oaky style, with tropical fruit and some residual sugar. Impressive and layered, if not wholly elegant and refreshing- 14.5