Nicolas Belfrage: (cc: water-pale = 1; deep gold = 9) cc2. Green-apple or pear nose. Very acid, and from that point of view, very Pinot, but there is not enough behind in the way of redeeming features. Still, it’s clean and fresh and really quite acceptable; a good effort- 13

Marcel Orford-Williams: Austere. Bone-dry, clean, fruity, but not a lot of fun- 12.5

Joanna Simon: Very pale. Strange, “rotten,” honeyed, caramel nose. Bone-dry palate, mediumbodied; minerally with fresh acid and a little creaminess, but not enough to give it life or make up for the off-putting nose- 9