Nicolas Belfrage: Correct Nebbiolo aromas and sweet, evolved fruit—perhaps a bit too evolved for its age. But drinking well now and quite correct. 14

Simon Larkin: Bright but no great intensity of color. Creamy, damson fruit, but loose and lackluster, as if the soul has departed. Almost cream-soda notes. There is a confection here that is so disappointing, especially in the context of this tasting. Anonymous, one-dimensional, straightforward. A shame. 9

Franco Ziliani: Brilliant ruby color, full of energy. The nose is complex and very elegant, with great Nebbiolo typicity: rose, tar, spice, game, leather, cherry, plum, and earthy violets. Very rich but well balanced, with very good body, powerful tannins, and a very persistent finish. Still young, with good aging potential. Drinkable now; even better with age. 18