Nicolas Belfrage: Unusually light color, but correct for Nebbiolo. Slight reduction on the nose (could be oak) compromises an otherwise well-structured wine. The wine is potentially good but flawed. 7

Simon Larkin: Modest hue, some solidity. The aromas suggest confected, cherry fruit, lacking freshness or richness. The palate lacks poise, purity, and complexity; very contrived and simple in style, despite some substance. Sound, nothing more. 8

Franco Ziliani: Brilliant ruby color of medium intensity. The nose is very old-style, with earthy, gamey, slightly “animal” notes, truffle, dried mushroom, aromatic herbs, and rhubarb. The taste is very appealing and satisfying, with layers of fruit, earthy tannins, cocoa powder, and salty mineral notes. Vibrant acidity and a long, straight finish. Splendid with game. Could be drunk now, but lay down some bottles if, like me, you enjoy the rustic character of more mature Barbaresco! 16.5