Stephen Brook: Delicate lime nose; has charm rather than power. Medium-bodied, a bit slack, attractive silky fruit, but lacks some grip and acidity. Seems quite evolved, not enough zip. 13

Margaret Rand: Relatively light, elegant, and with a very long finish. Somehow lacks an edge of excitement compared to some of the others, but it’s still very good. Excellent balance; still quite tight, with a big finish. 16

Jancis Robinson: For the moment the nose is lightweight, but it somehow convincingly suggests that there is much more of interest to come. Honey and blossom on the nose with real zest and a firm line of acidity. Sleek texture. Excellent tension and persistence. Fine and elegant. Drink 2011–22. 18