Nicolas Belfrage: Col code 2. Again a bit neutral non nose. Also a bit dull as if oxidized. 2nd bottle is the same. Very dull. 10

Michael Edwards: Quite sprightly and aerian, depending less on mineral than fruit profile. Honorable, but not exceptional. 15.5

Franco Ziliani: Very pale, anonymous color. Elegant, fresh, flowery nose with some salty mineral “volcanic” accent. Good freshness, crisp acidity, long and vertical with a salty full of savor subtle finish. 14.5