Michel Bettane: Big and deep color, very ripe and harmonious on the nose, great style, lovely fruit, perfect integration of oak, up to the best classified growth; a new star is born, with a superb Margaux typicity. 17.5

Thierry Desseauve: Pure and fruity aromas, less oaky than most of the others. This wine has muscles and an excellent terroir. Race, complexity, and finesse. 18

Michael Schuster: Fresh and sweetly ripe in flavor, with a very fine-textured tannin and good length; stylish, gently complex Margaux, which should make a very pleasing glass when mature. 2018–30. 16