Essi Avellan | Deep lemon color. Elegant and expressive nose, with pineapple, confectionary, and petrol nose. Succulent, zesty, intense, with noticeable sweetness but a good balance. | 17

Marcel Orford-Williams | Very up front. Saline, yes, but lacks fat. Good grip, yes, but lacks body. | 15.5

Tom Stevenson | Fat, sappy fruit, which must come from limestone, from its chalky minerality, though there is no chalk in Alsace, of course. | 17