Richard Mayson: Golden Delicious apple aromas, scented but a bit synthetic; very dry and austere in style, hard steely edge without much fruit on the palate. Simple, clean finish. 12

Charles Metcalfe: Delightful, citrussy aromas, hint of honey. Balanced acidity; lemon and honey flavors. Fresh, crisp, invigorating; gently honeyed finish. Maybe starting to fade from its best. 12

Joanna Simon: Fresh, lifted, floral and green-apple and pear aromas, with a little chalkiness. Tight, mineral palate, with green apple and grapefruit. Medium intensity with salty, oyster-shell length and well-sustained acidity. Bone-dry. 15.5