Simon Field | Dense color, and impressive briny nose; linseed, resin, mint, herbs, and then, finally, some dark fruit. The palate has a similar match-struck tension, black tea, After Eight mints, and, in search of the home chord, the recognition that there are probably too many characters in search of an author. | 88

Andrew Jefford | Deep though translucent black-red. Smoky, ashy scents; a sweet earthiness at best. Moderately attractive. This is concentrated but rather raw in style. | 82

David Williams | Like a supercharged version of a certain strain of New World Pinot Noir, this has a powerful orange citrus character initially. It’s super- concentrated but consistently refreshing and supple, a note of paprika spice coming in there, too, even a touch of sage. An uncompromising but compulsively drinkable expression. | 89