Michael Edwards: This has much more in hue, scent, and flavor. Rich summer fruits of your favorite orchard, richness and poise. 92

Simon Field: Red fruits darken the hue, but enliven nose and palate alike; redcurrants, figs, and hints of soft spice; grip is not forsaken, with a subtle red-fruit backdrop presaging a measured evolution. | 88

Anne Krebiechl: Slight golden color. A hint of green freshness on the nose, then on the palate, a very fresh, easy, lively, and almost primary sense of freshness. This is brisk, taut, young, and fizzing with lively, fresh mousse. One feels it needs more time, but its balance is assured. | 93