Gerard Basset: Medium green-yellow. Intense duxelle-of-mushroom nose, agreeable but a bit simple. Ripe structure, powerful retro-olfaction, medium finish. 17
Marcel Orford-Williams: Good nose, reasonably good colour. Bit orange peel dryish and dull. 14
Roy Richards: Marcel says that 2002 Tokay was rotted to hell. Nose is sweet and vegetal, slightly sour on the palate, poor example. 8
Details
| Wine expert | Roy Richards Marcel Orford-Williams Gerard Basset |
| Tastings year | 2005 |
| Region | Alsace |
| Appellation | AOC |







