Michael Schuster: Pale orange-gold; a strong combination of honey and coconutty oak on the nose; a medium-full wine; nicely concentrated, elegantly balanced wine, indeed rather less hefty than usual; very sweet, quite complex, and with good, light length. 2016–30. 16/16.5

Michel Bettane and Thierry Desseauve: Classic Haut-Bommes, with more freshness than others; notes of citrus and white fruit, precisely defined flavors and sweetness; extremely long, elegant, condensed, just a touch of oak for now. 18.5