Stephen Brook: Medium straw. Light, fresh apricot nose, lean and elegant. Fairly rich, broad, rather heavy with a hint of bitterness. This is dull and lacks any elegance or vigour. Medium length. 13

Simon Field: Steely, mineral-driven nose, with notes of ginger and lime blossom lurking. A fine example, with perfect purity of texture and acidity buttressing impressively – sometimes a little too impressively perhaps. 15