Stephen Brook: Rich oaky nose, rather oily: bananas and other tropical fruit. Reasonably fresh, though rounded and plump, but moderate acidity deprives it of some zest. Attractive exotic fruit but forward. 16

Michael Schuster: Pale gold; rich, ripe, citrussy aromas; palate mirrors nose: rich, juicy, and fresh, combining vivid citrussy flavors and a nice mid-palate length, with clear premier cru raciness and excellent persistence; very good premier cru Meursault. 2009-15. 16.5