Nicolas Belfrage: Fairly deep with a bit of turn. Sour cherry on nose. More morello on palate, good acidity. I like the fruit but oak gets in the way. Somewhat one-dimensional. Drink 20012-2020. 14

Roy Richards Deep, but with penumbra, this seems the real thing: intense, a little floral. Second nose is edgy, black fruit. A pretty wine. 17

Franco Ziliani: Good color, very round supple and fruity nose, cherry, plum, earthy, some licorice, wild notes with a hint of oak. Good structure, fleshy wine with good and fresh fruit, interesting complexity,. Still young but with a good potential of ageing. The finish is just a little dry, but is good wine. 14.5