Michael Schuster: Dense and closed to smell, but gravel and minerals behind the dark fruit; elegant middleweight wine, moderately concentrated, finely tannic, fresh rather than vital; lovely restrained harmony, a long, gently complex, refined Pibran, neither particularly concentrated nor particularly muscular, but complete and delicious, and with good light, length. This will certainly make a lovely bottle when fully mature. 2024–35. 90–92