Essi Avellan: Stylish nose, with smoke and toast, lactic characters, too. Fine, linear, focused structure and enough length. Nice, fine-tuned whole. 87

Anthony Rose: Pale in color; fine nutty aromas with a hint of brioche. Well-crafted fizz, with expansive, full-flavored appley mousse etched with cleansing citrusy acidity, while retaining a light toasty-rich flavor and finishing with a mouthwateringly, zestily clean dry tang. 92

Tom Stevenson: Simplistic core of fruit, with notes of bruised apple and cigarette ash. 78