Michel Bettane: Lovely cedary nose; middleweight body; elegant texture; first-class integration of oak; style and complexity in a most classical style. Only the last touch of intensity is lacking for reaching greatness 17

Thierry Desseauve: Brilliant color, superb aromas (mahogany, flowers, little red fruits, freshness); delicate but tense length, deep, fine body, perfect balance. Magnifique! 18

Michael Schuster: Fine, fragrant, cassis Cabernet nose; very nicely balanced, fresh yet supple wine, with a fine, dry tannin; crisply ripe, gently sweet red-fruit flavor, complex, subtle, mineral-infused, and with excellent fruit length. Delicacy and definition—archetypal Margaux. Needs time. 2016–28+ 16.5 +