Michael Edwards: A step up here: a complete, harmonious wine, clear, ripe but refreshing, fruity Chardonnay leading. Good weight without heaviness 16

Simon Field: Nose still enigmatic, despite having had nearly a decade to decide where to go; citric notes on the palate are married to yellow fruit and hints of spice. The finish is poised and refined, linear and crisp 16

Tom Stevenson: Mellow, gentle richness 17