Tim Atkin: Mid-straw, with a hint of gold. Rich, honeyed, some development, texture. Good acid lifts the fruit here, framing it beautifully. Zesty crab-apple finish; minerality and length and freshness and complexity. Rich wine, lots of levels. Good length 17

Jesús Barquín: Golden yellow, with green hues. Serious, intense, with good fruit notes; reasonably dry on the palate, persistent, well structured, and long 15.5

Simon Field: An evolved nose, with hints of honeysuckle. The palate is a little stewed and perhaps a little too sweet and tiring quite quickly; falls away at the back 14.5