Tim Atkin: Very pale straw. Oaked nose? Some vanilla spice, good acidity, but finishes a tad short and oak-dominated. High acid, slightly lacking in fruit weight. Citrus, some apple. Pear-drop finish. Estery 13.5

Jesús Barquín: Straw yellow, almost transparent. Balsamic laurel-bay notes, aromatic, with a hint of pineapple, perhaps slightly too exotic. Very long within a forward and subtropical style 14.5

Simon Field: Soft lime-green color; pungent nose, with hints of almonds and pear skin; youthful and expressive; the palate is attractive, albeit a little softer than expected, wrapping up the ensemble with gentle milky charm 15.5