Nicolas Belfrage: (cc: water-pale = 1; deep gold = 9) cc3. Pinkish tinge. Disastrous nose of sweaty jodhpurs. Palate not too bad but definitely one not to drink if you can avoid it. Acidity high; flavor: n’en parlons plus - 7

Marcel Orford-Williams: Not much on the nose but quite delicious. Clean and fruity, with length; even manages some charm- 17

Joanna Simon: Palish, very slightly pinkish. Understated floral, appley, light creamy nose; a hint of smoke. Dry, appley, appetizingly mineral palate with medium concentration. Mediumbodied; fresh, but could do with just a little more acid to give it verve- 14.5