Michael Edwards: A richer tone to this, but near its peak 15
Simon Field: Mature, slightly maderized nose; palate is rich and mushroomy with marked volatility and no shortage of vestigial charm 17
Tom Stevenson: Oxidative, rich, but lacking balance and finesse 14
Details
| Wine expert | Michael Edwards Simon Field Tom Stevenson |
| Tastings year | 2012 |
| Region | Champagne |
| Appellation | Champagne AOC |







