Michael Edwards: Just the tiniest hint of oeil de perdrix hue (pinkish); little red fruits, gentle mouthfeel, subtle and refreshing, quite pure. A simple wine, but none the worse for that 15.5

Simon Field: Distinctive pink tints here and a rather precocious red-fruit nose with baking spice and sourdough evidenced. Palate underlines the assertive and rather bullying oak, which may or may not eventually aspire to learn its place 14

Tom Stevenson: Copper-tinged, high acids, smoky fruits, dusky English style 16