Michael Edwards: Tint of color: a blanc de noirs? Gentle flowing bubbles; fresh nose for ripe ’09, bouncy acidity. Acidity apparent on the palate, though giving energy rather than aggression; flavors of little red fruits, natural and attractive. Medium length. Good 16

Tom Stevenson: This is Camel Valley Pinot Noir Brut ! I always recognize it, but I am always shocked by how beautifully it drinks. Little things like its very pale, Roederesque color and silky mousse are perfect—no other word does the wine justice. The orchard fruits are so soft, fresh and pure, with the acidity providing vitality. Just sublime! 18.5