Nicolas Belfrage: Col code 2. Ripe apple aromas. OK acid/fruit but pulls up a bit short, doesn’t fill the mouth. Slightly clumsy on finish. 12

Michael Edwards: Pale yellow gold, elegant and bright. Controlled ripeness meshing with golden fruit and a nice touch of spice. The maturity of the year perhaps masks much sense of terroir but this has the svelte texture of a made wine in a good sense. 16

Franco Ziliani: Bright, golden-pale color with many reflects on the glass. The nose is interesting and complex with an appealing mix of fruity peach and some apple and flowery notes with a zesty citrus accent and just a hint of spice. Good consistence on the palate, with freshness, medium body, an almond note, a lively, strong acidity. Still very young. 15