Richard Mayson: CO2 spritz evident, minerally aromas, clean and spritzy on the palate, with good appley length; not much character, but fresh, zesty, and well made. 13.5

Charles Metcalfe: Lemony, with a faintly terpenic note to the aromas. Gentle, just a hint of residual sugar. Attractively lemony, with this whiff of pine forest. Highish acidity, bracing. 13.5

Joanna Simon: Zesty sweet orange and spice aromas. Spritz on the palate, with sweet tangerine, apple, and even apricot; quite a lot of RS— medium-dry; gentle, balanced acidity, but sweetness submerges the minerality and the quintessential green-fruit Vinho Verde character. 12.5