Essi Avellan: Medium-deep peach color. Fresh, lemony, tart red-fruit nose with a little toast. Crisp, lively palate, with great freshness and focus. Delightfully light and refreshing. 19

Simon Field: Onion-skin color and a reticent nose; the palate is marked by real concentration, firm acidity, and an impressive structure. Child of a superb vintage, albeit rather a young one, this has a long future ahead of it. Outstanding and harmonious concentration. 17.5

Tom Stevenson: Very pale peach color, lovely fresh orchard fruits, nicely brut dosage, great acids. This is a Champagne rosé that would repay both with food and aging a few years. 17.5