Essi Avellan: Deep cherry-red color. Attractive, sweet strawberry nose, with light underlying toasty character. Fresh and succulent palate, with noticeable but balanced dosage. Easy to like and clearly well made. Smart style. 17

Simon Field: Ripe nectarine coloring introduces a wine with a slightly loose-knit aromatic and then an equally perplexing palate, which is not sure whether it wishes to belong to the old or more modern school and slips, slightly clumsily, between the two of them. 14

Tom Stevenson: Medium Tavel rosé color, with acids and fruit of little distinction. 12