Essi Avellan: Pale peachy color. Elegant, developing toast and autolysis-dominant nose with peachy white-fruit character. Crisp, zesty, vivacious. A fine 2004 full of life and highly elegant. Delightful. 18.5

Simon Field: Softer onion-skin color, with a poised herbal aroma; then a palate that is deceptively powerful, dried-fruit and measured tannins providing support to the ensemble, which has great potential for gastronomic accompaniment. 15.5

Tom Stevenson: Lovely pale peach color, but it’s the fine acids that lift this rosé, which is very fruity but not too fruity. Clean, fresh, crisp finish. 16.5