Jamie Goode | This is quite deeply colored, with a slight haziness. It has an intense citrussy nose with some nice spicy detail. The palate has amazing freshness, concentration, and poise, with a lovely mineral core and a slight saltiness, as well as pure citrus fruit. A thrilling wine that should age effortlessly for 15–20 years. Finishes with finely chiselled acidity. | 95

Peter Richards | Deepish lemon hue. Evolution notable in the aromas—honeyed tones, dried herbs, and fruit as well as fresher elements. Dry but fairly short, too. Shame! Limited scope on show here, despite some decent Semillon character. Drink soon, I would suggest. | 85

David Williams | Super-bright and tangy, a sour-lime attack that seems rather tight and ungiving for now—is it in a difficult stage? There’s excellent concentration, but not a lot of detail or finesse at the moment. | 88