Andrew Jefford | Full mid-gold. Bottle 1: Very strange, raw aromas, entirely unseductive and untypical. Bottle 2: Not notably di erent. Still raw and rather bean-like. Atypical. All the oddity is there on the palate, too: not a success. | 74

Charles Metcalfe | Really unappealing rot character. This is not good wine and will never be anything other than tainted by rot. | 70

Jancis Robinson | Pale straw. Sticky nose. Just sweet and simple. Raw finish. Clumsy. And indeed a bit sickly. Second bottle equally heavy, if not more so. Very sweet. Drink 2017–20. | 86