Stephen Brook: Rich ripe nose, peaches, has underlying minerality, too. Rich and juicy, abundant upfront fruit, integrated acidity, has zest and flair. Perhaps there's no great complexity here, but it delivers the goods in terms of fruit and balance. Good length. 17.5

Jancis Robinson: Markedly spritzig. Very pungent, almost as though there is a hint of Scheurebe in here! Minerals and canned grapefruit. Lots of gas - some people may object. Still unintegrated, though certainly memorable. Excellent acidity - really racy. 16

Alexander Scott: Bottle stink masks all at present. But the palate is really piercing - electric, in fact. In ten years I think this should be outstanding. Not easy to assess now, though. Hmmm... tentative score based on potential. 17