Gerard Basset: Pale silver-yellow. Mineral and earthy, modest fruit character. Slightly unbalanced, short finish. 11.5
Marcel Orford-Williams: Quite sweet, touch of rot. Alcoholic, not especially well balanced. Hot. 13
Roy Richards: First bottle: corked. Second bottle: despite the botrytis here, quite refined, hazelnut. Tasting it, warmer than the others, but it seems that the balancing acidity is not quite there. Non. 12
Details
Wine expert | Roy Richards Marcel Orford-Williams Gerard Basset |
Tastings year | 2005 |
Region | Alsace |
Appellation | AOC |
Marc Kreydenweiss

