Alison Buchanan: Cat’s pee, plastic erasers and some spice marred by cardboard notes. The latter nuances, sadly, dominate the palate. Sickly. 5

Nicolas Belfrage: Nose somewhat attenuated but lively palate, green apple, yeast-bread. Good balance and length. Very drinkable if not at all spectacular. 14

Alex Hunt: Fairly neutral aromatically, but very nice weight and balance in the mouth. Gentle, lemony fruit, good concentration. Slightly chalky texture in an appetising way. 16